A Simple Guide to Sugar Cookie Dough


A doughnut sitting on top of a cutting board

It doesn’t take long to find recipes calling for egg-free sugar cookie dough. If you check your local grocery store, you are almost bound to find the white stuff in every single aisle. If it’s not there, you will find the occasional ingredient such as egg white, vanilla or a pinch of nutmeg listed. That means that you can be stuck making traditional cookie dough if you don’t check the sugar cookie recipe books first. Egg free isn’t the only thing you need to worry about when baking with egg-free sugar cookie dough. There are many other issues that you will want to be aware of before getting started.

Know The Ingredients

A close up of food

The ingredients are the same between homemade and purchased sugar cookie dough. They just come in a different form. For example, vegetable oil is a liquid, not a solid, that you will need to mix with the flour to make the mix smooth enough to roll with. If you have a food processor, it will make the task a lot easier. A food processor has a blade and a scraper attached to it. Simply mix all the things together and start your work.

Many websites claim that egg free is healthier than regular sugar but this is actually a myth. There is simply no difference in the nutritional content between the two. However, the texture is very different. Sugar cookies have a smoother and softer feel to them, which many people prefer.

If you don’t have the time to mix your own flour, then don’t despair. Any type of flour can be used in a sugar cookie recipe. Some good options are old-fashioned flour and pastry flour. Baking is after all an enjoyable experience, not just a chore. If you don’t mind using the less expensive flour, go ahead and do so.

Special Egg Free Icing

A close up of food

Many sugar cookie recipes call for a special egg free icing. You can substitute white cake flour for egg-free icing if you prefer. However, don’t use cornstarch as a thickener as it will create lumps in the batter. Also, don’t add any flaxseed oil, instead use ground flaxseed oil. The result will be a light and fluffy dessert with a tangy, peanut flavor.

The key to making great sugar cookie dough is chilling it to the right temperature. It is best to store your cookie dough in the refrigerator because it allows for longer mixing. It is also important to mix your dough with cold water as opposed to warm water. This will help reduce the risk of developing lumps and bumps in your dough. Remember that you should make about three times the amount of cookies that you are going to bake in order to avoid having trouble finding the right consistency.

Preheat Your Oven To 350 Degrees

Before baking your sugar cookie recipe, preheat your oven to 350 degrees. Then, using an egg-free baking flour, mix the dry ingredients (except for the water) together until the mixture begins to form a dough. Once this stage is complete, switch the temperature to medium and place your mixture into the oven. Once the timer goes off, check to ensure that the temperature is still warm.

Bottom Line 

The most difficult part of making your own sugar cookie dough is waiting for it to rise. If you try to mix the dough after it has nearly finished rising, you will have a lot of lumps and bumps in your finished product. Therefore, it is imperative that you allow your mix to mix for at least five minutes. After the five minutes are up, check the temperature of your mix to ensure it is still at the proper temperatures. That is all there is to making great sugar cookie dough.

Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter